Complaints & Appeals
CMB takes complaints seriously and aims to resolve them fairly and transparently. Complaints may relate to editorial decisions, peer review, ethics, or published content.
Appeals of editorial decisions
- Authors may appeal decisions by providing a structured response to reviewers’ and editors’ comments.
- Appeals are reviewed by a senior editor not involved in the original decision when feasible.
- Appeal outcomes are final.
Ethics complaints
- Concerns about plagiarism, data/image manipulation, compromised review, or citation coercion should be reported to the Editorial Office.
- CMB may request evidence and may contact authors’ institutions where appropriate.