CMB uses double‑blind peer review. Authors and reviewers must not disclose identifying information during the review process.

Minimum review standard

  • At least two independent external reviewers are invited for research articles (exceptions must be justified).
  • Editors assess reviewer reports for quality and completeness.
  • Editors may request additional reviews when reports conflict or when integrity concerns arise.

Confidentiality and conduct

  • Reviewers must treat manuscripts as confidential and must not use unpublished information for personal advantage.
  • Reviewers must declare COI and decline review when appropriate.
  • Personal criticism is inappropriate; reviews must be evidence‑based.

Mandatory citation checks (reviewer form)

Reviewers must explicitly assess whether references are relevant and correctly cited in context, and identify inappropriate or missing key citations. Any pattern suggestive of citation manipulation must be reported to the editor.